MTG Commander/Elder Dragon Highlander
http://mtgcommander.net/Forum/

An idea for making mana drought less of an issue
http://mtgcommander.net/Forum/viewtopic.php?f=7&t=19007
Page 1 of 1

Author:  Skyknight [ 2018-Nov-22 11:18 am ]
Post subject:  An idea for making mana drought less of an issue

Someone on a weblog I frequent said that she did find Commander the most enjoyable of the formats she'd played, but still had some misgivings about the overly random nature of land availability. So I've been wondering, is there a way to fix that, without running into power excess? I think I might have hit on a possible answer.

Namely, the command zone isn't just for commanders. It also gets to play host to a few lands.

Specifically, I'm thinking you can have in your command zone three basic lands of your choice, or two basic lands of your choice and Command Tower. And yes, these count towards the 100. You can play a command zone land in just the same way you'd play a land from your hand. If lands originating from the command zone get exiled/destroyed/tucked/etc., they can be returned to the command zone instead. The trick is making sure that CZ lands don't get confused with other basic lands. I doubt anyone would be dim enough to blow up a CZ land unless they were desperate to lock out a bit of your mana for just one turn, but...

Author:  Inkeyes22 [ 2018-Nov-22 11:33 am ]
Post subject:  Re: An idea for making mana drought less of an issue

So I play Zo-Zu the Punisher or some other general that doesn't need more than 3 lands and 96 other cards? That would be a lot of gas.

Author:  Viperion [ 2018-Nov-22 2:08 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: An idea for making mana drought less of an issue

Only if you start with 4 cards in hand, for what I hope are obvious reasons.

Author:  Sovarius [ 2018-Nov-23 11:52 am ]
Post subject:  Re: An idea for making mana drought less of an issue

Inkeyes22 wrote:
So I play Zo-Zu the Punisher or some other general that doesn't need more than 3 lands and 96 other cards? That would be a lot of gas.

I thought of Flash Hulk and 4c stax since those are my current jim jams. But like the 'social contract' this is something you would only do with friends and similarly powered decks. It doesn't seem to port very well to random groups because i would absolutely make a deck with very few lands if i can just start with 3 in my extra hand. But doing so makes your deck just suck when you play 10 lands without the rule.

Author:  OldVig [ 2018-Nov-25 9:36 am ]
Post subject:  Re: An idea for making mana drought less of an issue

Skyknight wrote:
misgivings about the overly random nature of land availability.

Skyknight wrote:
If lands originating from the command zone get exiled/destroyed/tucked/etc., they can be returned to the command zone instead.

What are you actually trying to fix?
Quote 1 suggests variance is the problem (which you can mitigate with more lands / mana rocks).
Quote 2 suggests land destruction is the problem, and seriously, most lands that do get destroyed in a fair game are fair game (e.g. Gaia's Cradle)

Author:  Kemev [ 2018-Nov-25 10:14 am ]
Post subject:  Re: An idea for making mana drought less of an issue

I really like this idea. I think it's fair (in the sense that it benefits all players, and scales between the different styles of play), and I think it adds to the fun (no one wants to sit and watch their friends play for 45 minutes 'cause they're short a land).

If I were gonna suggest this to my groups, I'd probably keep it to 1 basic... 3 feels like it makes the game too easy, and the Command Tower is too good for multicolor decks.

Author:  ragscoon [ 2019-Feb-18 6:43 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: An idea for making mana drought less of an issue

I like the idea, a friend told me about this once at our local game shop. I thought was a good way to fight off mana issues but I think keeping it to two basic lands and starting with 5 hard hand is much more fair and it should be an option, if you want the mana then you have to start with a 5 card hand.

Author:  Kemev [ 2019-Feb-20 10:22 am ]
Post subject:  Re: An idea for making mana drought less of an issue

...I liked the idea with 1 basic, but even the 1 land is too good for Seton and some of the other elf-y generals.

Page 1 of 1 All times are UTC - 7 hours
Powered by phpBB © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007 phpBB Group
http://www.phpbb.com/