MTG Commander/Elder Dragon Highlander
http://mtgcommander.net/Forum/

Someone refuses to honor the banlist--happened to you?
http://mtgcommander.net/Forum/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=12779
Page 1 of 6

Author:  TheEvilCliff [ 2012-Nov-25 6:56 pm ]
Post subject:  Someone refuses to honor the banlist--happened to you?

At my local store, I've been trying--hard--to ease people away from only playing combo blue.

(Let's face it, a combo blue deck can win the game and answer other combo blue decks most of the time, but that's a different story)

Between rounds, two others and I sat down for an EDH game, and one of the guys pulled out a deck that wasn't combo blue. Momir Vig, to be precise.

He then asked, "I haven't taken Primeval Titan out yet, is that ok? I don't agree with the ban, I don't think PT is worth banning."

I told him two things: One, that the 3rd player and I had built decks to the most common set of rules, the official ones found here. For him to try and build to a different standard, out of disagreement of laziness, seemed a bit dodgy to me. (This is a guy who claims to be a Rules Advisor, yet just Friday, tried to Dreadbore an enchantment.)

Two, I said that the second he tutors for PT before he finds anything else, he's proving the RC's point.

We played, and the third guy's Kaalia took over fast. Turned out to sort of be a moot point, but I'm a bit offended.

I'd like to hear if others have gone through similar things. House bans I know about, but house un-bans are new to my ears.

Should I have handled it differently?

Author:  cryogen [ 2012-Nov-25 10:43 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Someone refuses to honor the banlist--happened to you?

House rules allow for both banning and unbanning a card. Since you're playing at your store, hopefully everyone can come to an agreement.

Author:  Sheldon [ 2012-Nov-26 12:14 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Someone refuses to honor the banlist--happened to you?

cryogen wrote:
House rules allow for both banning and unbanning a card. Since you're playing at your store, hopefully everyone can come to an agreement.


And when you can't agree, the official rules are there to serve you.

Author:  Malekoda [ 2012-Nov-26 1:12 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Someone refuses to honor the banlist--happened to you?

I wouldn't have let him play with it. Adhering to the banlist is one of the rules of the format - like having a 99+1 deck, starting at 40 life and 7 cards, etc. Insisting on playing a banned card is tantamount to saying that you don't want to play Commander but prefer your own little made-up format.

Author:  moraff [ 2012-Nov-26 1:31 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Someone refuses to honor the banlist--happened to you?

Meh, when people do that, I say sure, I have a deck that I disagree with a ruling on too. Then I pull out my Karn Deck and swap Karn for Emmy. Normally we agree with ban lists afterwards.

Author:  pi [ 2012-Nov-26 2:04 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Someone refuses to honor the banlist--happened to you?

When I joined the group they told me they play cards as written and don't adhere to any banlists. They quickly gave in on the former (apparently the revised Blessing doesn't say until end of turn, showing that pretty much convinced them on the folly, though one kept insisting that Candelabra of Tawnos doesn't tap for a while) and other than 2 mana vaults I've rarely seen any of their decks contain cards that shouldn't be there. I did make it clear that if that was really what they wanted I'd be happy to build some decks that would demonstrate why there are banned/restricted lists.

I could accept that someone hasn't yet gotten to updating their deck, I can be busy too and it took some weeks before my Primeval Titan was removed from my Mayael deck. I would indeed also ask that they won't tutor for it then and ask that they make sure to update the deck before we play again. Would they not change it I would likely refuse to play against that deck and make sure the reason is clear.

Author:  pookel [ 2012-Nov-26 2:42 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Someone refuses to honor the banlist--happened to you?

I was going to say "I'd put up with it if it just hadn't been fixed yet," and then I remembered the time that I realized mid-game that I had two Fallen Angels in my deck (shut up, there's two very different arts for it and I'd built in a hurry). I waited until the next time my deck was being shuffled and then pulled one copy out and replaced it with a land. It's not that hard to pull out Prime Time and put in a Forest if you haven't had time to really fix the deck yet.

Author:  cryogen [ 2012-Nov-26 3:42 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Someone refuses to honor the banlist--happened to you?

pi wrote:
When I joined the group they told me they play cards as written and don't adhere to any banlists. They quickly gave in on the former (apparently the revised Blessing doesn't say until end of turn, showing that pretty much convinced them on the folly, though one kept insisting that Candelabra of Tawnos doesn't tap for a while) and other than 2 mana vaults I've rarely seen any of their decks contain cards that shouldn't be there. I did make it clear that if that was really what they wanted I'd be happy to build some decks that would demonstrate why there are banned/restricted lists.

I could accept that someone hasn't yet gotten to updating their deck, I can be busy too and it took some weeks before my Primeval Titan was removed from my Mayael deck. I would indeed also ask that they won't tutor for it then and ask that they make sure to update the deck before we play again. Would they not change it I would likely refuse to play against that deck and make sure the reason is clear.

That's when you pull out your Island of Wak-Wak. "Sorry bro, the effect is indefinite."

Author:  Joz [ 2012-Nov-26 3:49 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Someone refuses to honor the banlist--happened to you?

pookel wrote:
I was going to say "I'd put up with it if it just hadn't been fixed yet," and then I remembered the time that I realized mid-game that I had two Fallen Angels in my deck (shut up, there's two very different arts for it and I'd built in a hurry). I waited until the next time my deck was being shuffled and then pulled one copy out and replaced it with a land. It's not that hard to pull out Prime Time and put in a Forest if you haven't had time to really fix the deck yet.

I've done that so many times with various pain lands and etbt lands, lol.

Thankfully, my binder is always at hand with a corresponding basic of my generals colors.

oops.

Author:  zimagic [ 2012-Nov-26 3:52 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Someone refuses to honor the banlist--happened to you?

moraff wrote:
Meh, when people do that, I say sure, I have a deck that I disagree with a ruling on too. Then I pull out my Karn Deck and swap Karn for Emmy. Normally we agree with ban lists afterwards.


Pretty much this, though not Emrakul specifically. It's usually just a discussion of what I can use off the banned list if he or she gets to use their pet card. The discussion generally winds up quickly with mention of Tolarian Academy or Recurring Nightmare.

I have had someone in my group refuse to allow me use Rebel Informer in a tribal Rebel deck though, which I understand but I found a bit annoying at the time all the same.

Author:  Joz [ 2012-Nov-26 3:54 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Someone refuses to honor the banlist--happened to you?

zimagic wrote:
moraff wrote:
Meh, when people do that, I say sure, I have a deck that I disagree with a ruling on too. Then I pull out my Karn Deck and swap Karn for Emmy. Normally we agree with ban lists afterwards.


Pretty much this, though not Emrakul specifically. It's usually just a discussion of what I can use off the banned list if he or she gets to use their pet card. The discussion generally winds up quickly with mention of Tolarian Academy or Recurring Nightmare.

I have had someone in my group refuse to allow me use Rebel Informer in a tribal Rebel deck though, which I understand but I found a bit annoying at the time all the same.



Is Rebel Informer overpowered in some way I can't understand?

Author:  brainface [ 2012-Nov-26 4:17 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Someone refuses to honor the banlist--happened to you?

Joz wrote:
Is Rebel Informer overpowered in some way I can't understand?

He's a repeatable tuck effect for Mistform Ultimus?

Author:  papa_funk [ 2012-Nov-26 4:34 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Someone refuses to honor the banlist--happened to you?

Eh, life's too short. Play the guy, mock him mercilessly when he immediately goes for PT, and if you think he's going to be an ongoing problem, decline a rematch.

Author:  zimagic [ 2012-Nov-26 5:10 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Someone refuses to honor the banlist--happened to you?

brainface wrote:
Joz wrote:
Is Rebel Informer overpowered in some way I can't understand?

He's a repeatable tuck effect for Mistform Ultimus?


No, the deck had (We built) Lin Sivvi as a general so they would have had to make an exception to the colour rule. I had no means or intention of producing black mana, his only out was being recruited. No go.

Author:  IotaNull [ 2012-Nov-26 7:48 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Someone refuses to honor the banlist--happened to you?

Speak of the devil... I had someone refuse to honour the banlist by playing Mox Pearl tonight. :|

Page 1 of 6 All times are UTC - 7 hours
Powered by phpBB © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007 phpBB Group
http://www.phpbb.com/